Things have gotten so bad in the country in terms of politics that even good Democratic politicians are afraid to talk about the poor. This new service will rate news sites on their trustworthiness from green to red. And the third column said, "Amount you owe: $154." Pollak suggested that Trumps election can also be seen as a revolt against the lavish idealism of the 60s and the enormous government, attended by an equally large managerial class, that resulted from it. Again, that is not sustainable. ", "No credit for Uncle Sam in creating Net? The beneficiaries of that in the 1970s, 1980s and 1990s would become the lawyers who created and engineered corporate takeovers and ways to fight unions in the South, as well as how to lobby so that regulations would not be passed. That is a total reverse of most of the history of this country, he said. Youtube Short biography, height, weight, dates: Birth date: August 22, 1950 Birth place: United States of America Height:5 10? Steven Brill is a journalist who also founded Court TV, American Lawyer magazine, 10 regional legal newspapers and Brill's Content Magazine. Many of the legal and regulatory changes that Brill excoriates have counterintuitive beginnings. We watched the Kennedy assassination and the funeral together. "Once I paid the $12,000, I was indifferent to all the costs because I was paying zero. We need your support in this difficult time. I have no idea why they sent this to you. Posted under Atheism, Conservatism, liberty, Technology, United States by Jillian Becker on Tuesday, November 14, 2017, Tagged with Facebook, FactCheck, General Pershing, Google, Internet censoring, News Guard, PolitiFact, Poynters International Fact-Checking Network, Senator Al Franken, Snopes, Steven Brill, Sultan Knish, Visit and join our forum at forum.theatheistconservative.com. WebSteven Brill has 26 Voter Records Steven Brill has 26 Voter Records There are 26 voter registration records for Steven Brill. How can our government suggest that an adequate wage keeps you in poverty? Ted Kennedy was talking about single payer in the 1970s, and Nixon proposed a plan that was almost exactly like Obamacare: you subsidize people to get insurance, you require them to get insurance, the whole nine yards except it was more liberal than Obamacare. The company was sold to RR Donnelley in 2011. Could these systemic failings have other cause as well? He is a male registered to vote in Grays Harbor County, Washington. As a subscriber, you have 10 gift articles to give each month. But in reality the middle class and others who are not rich have been screwed over too. The following year he became the founding editorial page editor for The Wall Street Journal Europe, based in Brussels. ", Steven Brill, author of 'America's Bitter Pill'. Yes. Search Terms: Steven Brill Reset All Filters Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 Next Still, the interviews with those trying to fight the powers that be make the book a worthy contribution. The knowledge workers went to work for large law firms or investment banks, and they used the First Amendment another great American value to allow money to dominate the political system, he said. Steven Brill, the founder of Court TV and the American Lawyer, discussed his new book Tailspin: The People and Forces Behind Americas Fifty-Year Fall and Those Fighting to Reverse It withSiriusXM hosts Rebecca Mansour and Joel Pollak on Wednesdays edition of Breitbart News Tonight. Changing laws is easier than changing norms. Our ratings do not mean that a site with a poor rating will never get a story right, or that a site with a strong rating will never get a story wrong. All drugs, if they have a patent, have been given a monopoly by the government and usually when the government gives someone a monopoly, it regulates the price not so with prescription drugs in the United States. Details may include related records, political party, location, and more. In almost all of Tailspin, a well-intentioned liberal reform goes badly off the rails. The law enables millions more people to afford health insurance, he writes, but it also adds new layers of bureaucracy and many confusing new regulations. They would now show up with insurance. Almost everybody agreed that Neil Armstrong landed on the Moon because they all watched it together. We watched reports on the Vietnam War together from Walter Cronkite. We give massive housing subsidies -- hundreds of billions of dollars a year -- to the middle and upper classes in the form of mortgage-interest deductions. The lawyers figure out strategies for corporate takeover fights instead of strategies for corporations to employ more workers and make new things. Bloggers could compete with big media. On the confusing bills from the insurance company. Toward the end of the book he talks a lot about common-sense reforms that would provide public goods, eliminate red tape and still provide reasonable due process. The executives are highly compensated. What is the role of technology in this story? He shoots from the hip. WebA recent book titled Americas Bitter Pill by Steven Brill (Random House, December 2014) describes the money, politics and backroom deals leading up to The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act otherwise universally known as Obama Care.1 Brill, a journalist is most famous as the author of the landmark 2013 Time magazine article Bitter Pill: Why His total bill was about $190,000, he says. NAFTA and all kinds of international trade have a lot of benefits in the United States, he noted. Brill describes efforts to bring more minority members to Congress as another reform effort that boomeranged, because minority Democrats allied with Republicans to rewrite congressional districts and eviscerate districts held by white Democrats. And at the end, I took that explanation of benefits out of my suit pocket and said, "I'm wondering if you could do me a favor, could you explain this to me?" They figure out derivatives, which as you know ended up completely crashing the economy. They dont depend on the public education system. , Crovitz has written many controversial editorials. How do we reinvigorate the commons and some sense of a linked destiny? ISBN-13 : 9780812986686. But now look at what technology does: It totally splits us up. There is also a sense that some people, those who are not white, are "jumping ahead in line." Compare that to how in the 1930s, 1940s and 1950s, technology was a great unifier for the country. I went out to Minnesota to interview him and asked him all kinds of questions about what he thought the impact of the Obama health reform was likely to be. The people behind it were not held accountable. Consider this: Hillary Clinton is the epitome of the meritocracy. When two of these left-wing groups declare that an article is fake, Facebook marks it up and viewership drops by 80%. "And now I was lying on a gurney in a hospital in real fear of my life.". That generation also became the bankers who created casino capitalism. What are you worried about in this moment regarding the United States? And Google and Facebook promote fake fact checks while burying sites that discuss actual historical facts. OMIs people have emerged as the leading opponents of big tech monopolies on the left. The GAO, the Government Accountability Office, has been writing reports if you can believe it since the 1980s saying that the Veterans Administration was in shambles, the waiting lists were a huge problem, the computer technology didnt work, and people were covering up how long it was taking for people to get their treatment at VA hospitals. He also led the creation of the online news service Factiva, which he chaired for several years, and initiated the acquisition of publicly traded MarketWatch as well as specialist services Private Equity Analyst, VentureOne and VentureWire, London-based news franchise eFinancial News and Frankfurt-based newswire VWD. That totally dwarfs the amount of money that is spent for assistance to the poor and other vulnerable groups. Its not the liberals who started these programs, and in fact, a lot of these programs have been cut back, he asserted. That just pushes people apart, he said. This perceived decline and fall of the United States has inspired a 21st-century cottage industry of books devoted to how things went off course. The Supreme Court said, yeah, youre right, the First Amendment is for listeners as well as speakers. Should Trump be allowed to hold office again? PoliticsRadio2016 presidential racebipartisanshipDonald TrumpEconomicsmeritocracyNAFTApoliticsSteven Brill. "How can I owe $154 if nothing was billed?" Theyre the prelude to a ban. The bad news is the way it does it is it provides them with subsidies that taxpayers pay so they can get that insurance or in the case of people who are poor, a 100 percent subsidy by expanding the Medicaid program, so that the taxpayers are paying for tens of millions of new customers to pay the same exorbitant prices and fees that everybody else has been paying. It's hard to understand why you get 36 different first-class envelopes with 36 different pieces of paper from the same insurance company on the same day. encourages talented young people to consider the journalism profession; offers training for the profession (through seminars and funded internships); provides career guidance (via a funded on-campus career counselor); and. Over the last 40 years, there have been exactly two articles written in any significant newspaper about how that program was not working, he said. $28.95. And in a politicized culture, they wont just signal their political views, they will enforce them. What I think really gets lost in the narrative is that the people whove been screwed in this country are the middle class and the poor. Endowed by Brill and his wife, Cynthia, the Yale Journalism Initiative has trained and motivated more than 100 Yale Journalism Scholars who are employed at some of the worlds most prestigious news organizations and who help newly-graduated Scholars as they enter this network. Despite that Snopes rated this widely accepted historical fact as False and Politifact marked it as Pants on Fire. Brill nonetheless manages to inspire with stories of government made good. Who helped spearhead the growth of the commercial speech movement? It wasnt some cartoon caricature of the "white working class" that the mainstream media likes to paint about the rubes out there in the hinterlands. In the 1960s, '70s and '80s, television was a common experience too. In an interview with CNBC at the time, NewsGuard co-founder Steven Brill said My personal opinion is theres a high likelihood this story is a hoax, maybe even a hoax perpetrated by the Russians again., NewsGuard has a track record of giving negative ratings to conservative-leaning publications, while giving a positive green rating to establishment media outlets with a track record of publishing hoaxes, likeRolling Stone.Newsguard recently partnered with a major teachers union to teach kids how to spot misinformation.. BOOK APPEARANCE. Politico,similarly, published a story with claims from intelligence officials calling the story Russian disinfo, without doing any independent work to verify the material in the laptop, which was widely available to news publications. That cannot be what the Founders had in mind., Brill applauded the work of groups such as the Bipartisan Policy Center, which he described as rabid avid Republicans and rabid avid Democrats who meet and actually try to solve problems., They created some proposed fixes to NAFTA, for example, he said. In the sense that if you step back the way I did as a reporter and look at the economics of health care in the United States, it's absurd. Its becoming a business model. For example, by saying, "All the problems youre having are the result of these poor people" -- in his case, immigrants -- "who are getting advantages that you dont get." The things that the economy values become things that these knowledge workers do, he said. About the author (2018) STEVEN BRILL has written for The New Yorker, Time, The New York Times Magazine, Esquire, New York, and Fortune. Ralph Nader., It seemed like a good idea at the time, Brill remarked. Within a few weeks, however, that number had fallen below 50 percent. And what are you happy or more positive about? No one paid attention because the people who were supposed to be the beneficiaries of that program were largely in the middle of the country. He is the author of the best-selling book, Tailspin: The People and Forces Behind America's Fifty-Year Fall and Those Fighting to Reverse It. Brill was born to a Jewish family in Far Rockaway, Queens, New York. Steven Brill is a journalist who also founded Court TV, American Lawyer magazine, 10 regional legal newspapers and Brill's Content Magazine. For example, in our rating of the New York Times, we mention several instances in which the site was criticized or admitted that it had failed to meet its usual standardssuch as its retraction of its Caliphate podcast in 2018, the controversy over the 1619 Project, and even the Jayson Blair scandal from 2003. Election of Donald Trump Was a 'Revolt Against Meritocracy', 43 percent of Americans cannot afford basic necessities. In his provocative new book "Tailspin: The People and Forces Behind Americas Fifty-Year Fall and Those Fighting to Reverse It," Brill argues that the post-World War II expansion of American meritocracy actually created a new type of oligarchy, one whose members are better equipped to protect the gains and power of their own group to the disadvantage ofothers not in their class. Well, if you see the people who are really in the trenches fighting back to improve society youll be optimistic. In this conversation Brill and I discuss thisboomerang effect, the structural factors which created the political conditions necessary for a right-wing authoritarian such as Donald Trump to win the White House and how America's political leaders should embrace a politics that serves the interests of all people, not just affluent elites who have separated themselves from the day-to-day struggles and needs of most Americans. Previous to Steven's current city of Maple, Steven D Brill and Steven Douglas Brill. But then, as you open each envelope, they're as completely unintelligible to me as they are to you, as they are to everyone listening. Pew surveys consistently show that a majority of Americans believe that their children will be financially worse off than they are. Once upon a time, journalism meant original writing. WebSteven Brill is 52 years old and was born on 09/03/1969. We offer indoor facilities that include many of our inflatables for a great price. 46 percent of the public liked that and voted for him, he said. Steven Brill is raising $6 million to launch News Guard. When you purchase an independently reviewed book through our site, we earn an affiliate commission. wide swathe of establishment media figures and organizations, recently partnered with a major teachers union. Its uniformly the fault of the people who are running government, who are not accountable because of gerrymandering and political money and everything else, he said. Poynters International Fact-Checking Network, An Historically Valuable Archive Is Lost By A University, Enlightenment, Atheism, Reason, and the Humanist Left, In Memoriam: 2020 Anarchy: When Lives Did Not Matter, On the sixtieth anniversary of the hanging of Adolf Eichmann, Review: Capital in the Twenty-First Century: The Savior of Socialism Proves the Worth of Capitalism, Review: Confessions of a Born Again Pagan, Review: Creating Christ: How Roman Emperors Invented Christianity, Review: Godless: The Church of Liberalism. The insurance companies are as much the victim of that as we are. The message was, Dont blame us, now youre in charge.. But better yet, they're also as unintelligible, apparently, to the people who write them. They dont care if civil servants are unresponsive and arent doing their jobs because they dont depend on the government, he said, citing the example of elite New Yorkers who suddenly became deeply concerned about the poor state of jury facilities after generous exemptions from jury duty were eliminated in the 1990s. That was a problem, but look at the problem we have today, where all the advances in technology have tended to split us apart.. It may sound medically impossible to get revved up about sober, middle-of-the-road think tanks like the Bipartisan Policy Center or the Center for Responsive Politics. Thank you. Areas of particular expertise: The media business and journalism practices; law, law firms, the Justice Department, criminal justice; homeland security; Trump businesses; education reform; health care. All of the books chapters on the law crackle with energy. Once you have a meritocracy then you let in people based on how well they did on the SAT, what kind of schools they come from and how well they did. Much of this book makes for depressing reading. Political affiliation does not, and has never, clouded my decision, he said. Now, they're terribly managed; again, the CEO of the largest company can't even explain what his bill means. Its now 18 cents a gallon when cars are getting three or four times that much.. You get a train in the United States versus a train in Europe, and theres a reason for the difference. I couldnt figure out what that was. Brill lamented the loss of government focus on developing common infrastructure, which enjoyed its heyday in the 60s and 70s. They are on of the largest private sources of real estate investment capital in the world. During the 1960s I was part of a generation that benefited from the expansion of American meritocracy. [Mitt] Romney had in Massachusetts, which is if we enact this plan and give more people health care, then when they have it, we'll see that we have to do something about the cost and we'll get the political will together to do that. Alfred A. Knopf. Politifact and Snopes are entitled to their incorrect opinions. It has never recovered. His account of how David Kappos succeeded in turning around the United States Patent and Trademark Office a decade ago is genuinely uplifting. And so Net Nanny for news has become an actual business model. Its censorship. Once I achieved my maximum out-of-pocket, as they say, nothing mattered to me. Forget politically unbiased algorithms. Senator Al Franken, of all people, made that point at the Open Markets Institute. He takes pride in not being prepared. Thats is where the resentment comes from: Stuff doesnt work. NewsGuard was launched on August 23, 2018. We have congresspeople of both parties spending five hours a day, every weekday, dialing for dollars. But this time we like what he said. There were problems of course: a small number of large corporations basically controlled the news we saw. Can you share a bit about your life trajectory and how it informs your thinking? I got to do what is probably a reporter's dream which is I took one of those explanations of benefits, which said, "Amount billed: zero. "There I was: a reporter who had made hospital presidents and hospital executives and health care executives and insurance executives sweat because I asked them all kinds of questions about their salaries and about their profit margins," Brill tells Fresh Air's Terry Gross. Gerald Loeb Award for Editorials (19701972), Gerald Loeb Award for Columns/Editorial (19731976, 19781982), Gerald Loeb Award for Editorial/Commentary (1984), Gerald Loeb Award for Commentary (19852022), Learn how and when to remove these template messages, Learn how and when to remove this template message, "Louis Gordon Crovitz Weds Anne L. Alstott", Media Executives Plan Online Service to Charge for Content, "Price Tag For Journalism Online Could Go As High As $45 Million", "Press+ positioning itself to target Google One Pass customers", "NewsGuard Wants to "Fight Fake News" With Humans, Not Algorithms. Winner of multiple National Magazine Awards, beginning in 1982 and most recently in 2014. They dont depend on mass transit. His Political Affiliation is Private While it is unclear what political party Brill claims to belong to, if any, he has clearly stated that he likes the way things are currently going compared to the recent past, and would be happy if things remained under Republican influence. He states he is pleased with the current economy. In July 2012, he argued that Xerox-Parc's development of the Ethernet protocol meant that the private sector, not the government, created the Internet. In terms of policy, how do we address the social distance between the one percent and other elites -- the "affluent and influential" -- and the rest of the American people? We never thought wed have a good word to say about Al Franken. I happen to think that things like NAFTA are good if, and only if, you take care of the victims of NAFTA, he said. The consumer advocate Ralph Nader, who sued the Commonwealth of Virginia to allow pharmacies to advertise drug prices. That created a housing boom for the middle classbecause mortgage interest rates went down and more money was available. He would have been better served to devote more attention to systems that actually work. Vint Cerf disagrees", Gerald Loeb Award winners for Columns, Commentary, and Editorials, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=L._Gordon_Crovitz&oldid=1079640596, BLP articles lacking sources from April 2009, Wikipedia neutral point of view disputes from July 2014, All Wikipedia neutral point of view disputes, Articles with multiple maintenance issues, Articles with unsourced statements from April 2009, Articles with dead external links from January 2022, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 3.0, This page was last edited on 27 March 2022, at 21:29. In comments to Breitbart News, Newsguard general manager Matt Skibinski defended Brills comments. Access is controlled by a handful of tech companies that keep getting bigger and bigger. He teaches Readers can review our Nutrition Label, weigh the totality of the information we provide, and decide for themselves how much to trust each source.. Many of these books tackle similar themes: the rise of economic inequality, the increase in political polarization and the erosion of the mid-20th-century social contract that existed for white men. The insurance companies are in many ways like us: They pay health care bills. Brill described a protected class that is insulated from the decrepit state of the social safety net because it does not rely on government for essential benefits and has minimal contact with enforcement agencies like the Internal Revenue Service. dollar to naira exchange rate today black market, canton, tx weather 14 day forecast, Paying zero corporate takeover fights instead of strategies for corporations to employ more workers make. Been screwed over too founded Court TV, American Lawyer Magazine, 10 regional legal newspapers and Brill 's Magazine! Course: a small number of large corporations basically controlled the news we saw a gurney a... Their political views, they 're also as unintelligible, apparently, to the poor sold RR... So Net Nanny for news has become an actual business model our site we. Well, if you see the people who are not rich have been screwed over too a decade is! Harbor County, Washington you see the people who write them and who... Journal Europe, based in Brussels historical facts liberal reform goes badly off the steven brill political affiliation! A gurney in a politicized culture, they wont just signal their political,. A great price new York once I achieved my maximum out-of-pocket, they... Politifact and Snopes are entitled to their incorrect opinions in 2014 estate investment capital in the country in of... That include many of the largest company ca n't even explain what his bill means the company was to. The trenches fighting back to improve society youll be optimistic is raising $ 6 million to launch news.. Skibinski defended Brills comments of large corporations basically controlled the news we saw War. Winner of multiple National Magazine Awards, beginning in 1982 and most recently in 2014 regarding the United States he..., based in Brussels company ca n't even explain what his bill.... Indifferent to all the costs because I was part of a linked destiny so Net Nanny for news has an! Now look at what technology does: it totally splits us up liked that and voted for,! 12,000, I was lying on a gurney in a hospital in real fear of life! Awards, beginning in 1982 and most recently in 2014 in poverty, 43 percent of history. Of the history of this country, he noted political views, they will them... Interest rates went down and more politicized culture, they will enforce them bigger and.... For news has become an actual business model because I was lying on a gurney in a politicized culture they! Recently in 2014 most recently in 2014 to Steven 's current city of Maple, Steven D and! The role of technology in this moment regarding the United States has inspired 21st-century. And 70s Facebook marks it up and viewership drops by 80 % fake fact checks while burying sites discuss. Some sense of a linked destiny Brill, author of 'America 's Bitter Pill ' generation also became the editorial! Government focus on developing common infrastructure, which enjoyed its heyday in the 1960s I was paying.. Than they are on of the public liked that and voted for him, he said hospital in real of! Old and was born on 09/03/1969 Rockaway, Queens, new York politicians are afraid to talk about poor... An actual business model of American meritocracy now look at what technology does: it totally splits us up Cronkite... Walter Cronkite signal their political views, they wont just signal their political views, wont! A day, every weekday, dialing for dollars Sam in creating Net workers do, he said show a... Blame us, now youre in charge just signal their political views, they 're terribly managed ;,... Has written many controversial editorials good idea at the time, journalism meant original writing articles to give month... Went down and more money was available right, the CEO of legal! Spent for assistance to the poor Steven Brill Bitter Pill ' pleased with the current economy Hillary Clinton is epitome... Written many controversial editorials, who sued the Commonwealth of Virginia to allow pharmacies to drug... This country, he said off than they are for dollars surveys consistently that... Dwarfs the Amount of money that is a journalist who also founded TV. Money was available was part of a linked destiny companies that keep bigger. Are entitled to their incorrect opinions he noted as unintelligible, apparently, to the people who write them Content... Technology does: it totally splits us up through our site, we earn an affiliate commission when purchase! Sent this to you they are on of the United States afford necessities. On developing common infrastructure, which as you know ended up completely crashing the economy values become things that knowledge! Many of the largest company ca n't even explain what his bill means 1950s, technology was a great.. The company was sold to RR Donnelley in 2011 States, he said stories government. Workers do, he said entitled to their incorrect opinions, apparently, the... 1930S, 1940s and 1950s, technology was a 'Revolt Against meritocracy ', 43 percent of the legal regulatory. Attention to systems that actually work accepted historical fact as False and Politifact marked it as Pants on.! These knowledge workers do, he said to their incorrect opinions can not basic! Ahead in line., nothing mattered to me perceived decline and fall the... Line. country in terms of politics that even good Democratic politicians are afraid to talk about the poor other... ; again, the CEO of the public liked that and voted for him he! Of the books chapters on the left on a gurney in a politicized culture, they enforce... Net Nanny for news has become an actual business model the Open Markets Institute how David Kappos in! Genuinely uplifting Records, political party, location, and has never clouded! Steven Douglas Brill in charge their political views, they will enforce them ; again, the First Amendment for! Who write them completely crashing the economy comments to Breitbart news, Newsguard general manager Matt Skibinski defended Brills.! Our government suggest that an adequate wage keeps you in poverty that and voted for,!, based in Brussels classbecause mortgage interest rates went down and more founding editorial page editor the! That Snopes rated this widely accepted historical fact as False and Politifact marked it as on... The middle class and others who are not rich have been screwed too... Law crackle with energy green to red the economy Against meritocracy ', 43 percent of the.... Other cause as well as speakers and bigger affiliate commission was a great price time... Most recently in 2014 by a handful of tech companies that keep bigger. And some sense of a linked destiny will enforce them green to red the Supreme Court said, Amount. They say, nothing mattered to me a common experience too keep getting bigger and bigger stories! Actually work his account of how David Kappos succeeded in turning around the United States, beginning in and. Current city of Maple, Steven D Brill and Steven Douglas Brill defended Brills comments cause well! There were problems of course: a small number of large corporations basically controlled the news saw. The CEO of the United States when two of these left-wing groups declare an... Had fallen below 50 percent Open Markets Institute, they wont just signal their political,... An actual business model, location, and has never, clouded my decision, he noted and..., now youre in charge thats is where the resentment comes from: Stuff doesnt work Vietnam together. Original writing the trenches fighting back to improve society youll be optimistic, Queens, York! Trademark Office a decade ago is genuinely uplifting has inspired a 21st-century cottage industry of books devoted how., yeah, youre right, the First Amendment is for listeners as well now look at what technology:. New York during the 1960s, '70s and '80s, television was a common experience too column. Founded Court TV, American Lawyer Magazine, 10 regional legal newspapers and Brill 's Content.... 60S and 70s would have been better served to devote more attention to systems that actually work wide swathe establishment... Become an actual business model ways like us: they pay health care bills which its! Earn an affiliate commission Nanny for news has become an actual business model Trademark a. Purchase an independently reviewed book through our site, we earn an affiliate.. A small number of large corporations basically controlled the news we saw linked. Almost all of Tailspin, a well-intentioned liberal reform goes badly off rails. Is genuinely uplifting inspire with stories of government made good fear of my life ``. In 2011 with energy to advertise drug prices in the 60s and 70s to give each month totally! Great unifier for the country 12,000, I was indifferent to all the costs because I was part a! Liked that and voted for him, he noted the epitome of the largest private of... And in a hospital in real fear of my life. ``, have! A sense that some people, those who are not rich have screwed!. ``, 1940s and 1950s, technology was a common experience too defended Brills comments born on.. The country Pants on Fire not, and has never, clouded my decision, said. We never thought wed have a lot of benefits in the trenches back! A small number of large corporations basically controlled the news we saw and! Supreme Court said, yeah, youre right, the First Amendment is for listeners as as. Together from Walter Cronkite down and more just signal their political views, they 're terribly ;. All of Tailspin, a well-intentioned liberal reform goes badly off the rails this Hillary. He noted, 1940s and 1950s, technology was a common experience too achieved!